Puccini, Manon Lescaut. Théâtre des Champs-Élysées, Paris – 12/11/26

Oliver Mears | director; Sarah Fahie | choreography; Annemarie Woods | scenography, costumes; Ricardo Pardo | designer; Fabiana Piccioli | Lights. Ailyn Pérez | Manon Lescaut; Roberto Alagna | The Chevalier des Grieux; Lionel Lhote | Lescaut; Nicola Ulivieri | Géronte de Ravoir; Orchestre National de France, conductor Lorenzo Passerini

I had another top of the house cheap seat for this performance but different from the one for Jaroussky last Sunday in that this was with a clear view of the stage, no impeding heads in the way, so I was able to follow all the action and had the full sound of the orchestra and singers, similar to being at the front of the Amphitheatre at ROHCG. It’s excellent value for money. The sound of the theatre is bright and lively, quite different from the often recessed sound of the London house. I have only ever seen Manon Lescaut once before, in Buxton Opera House in an English Touring Opera production – this was a bit of a mess dramatically, and of course with a reduced orchestra. So, this performance in Paris was a very different show, with the Orchestra National de France and star singers. I greatly enjoyed it,

It was also quite an interesting production. The overarching theme was the exploitation and objectification of women by men throughout the ages. In each of the 4 acts, there was an  opening front-of-curtains silent brief scene were some aspect of Manon’s hair was managed – before the first act, her father cutting chunks off before her becoming a nun, before the second, an elaborate hair do; her head shaved before the third, when she is a prisoner, and before the fourth, a frizzy wig, with mini skirt and black tights. Costumes move through the ages in each act – 18th century, with whalebone corsets for the ladies in act 1, vaguely Victorian act 2, probably early 20th century act 3, and contemporary in act 4. By Act 4, Manon has become a prostitute in a clever transition from the ‘desert’ of the libretto to a sleazy bar in ?New York or other big US city. The basic set was fairly bare – a big space that became the town square in act 1, big room in a fancy town house in act 2, a quay in act 3 and the bar in act 4. There was indeed a large rather boat shaped bar in act 4, a set of stairs. a sort of round raised space in the middle of the stage in act 1 that could have been a fountain or market space (but which people also danced on), and maybe a wardrobe or two in act 2, but very little else. Act 3 just had a set of white doors upstage, the entry to the convict ship – all the left-behind lovers drum frenziedly on the doors, alongside drums in the orchestra, in a last attempt to see their loved ones. All in all, action was clearly delineated – although there were French and English surtitles, these were so poorly illuminated as to be unreadable, but I was pretty clear about what was going on, the gathering hysteria at the end of act 2 was particularly well-done, and really quite exciting. The director was Oliver Mears of ROHCG – he did a good job here, and happily there were none of the counter-intuitive last-minute twists of plot he’s often used in his ROHCG productions.

Puccini’s music is less immediately attractive than his later big hitters – even La Rondine has a more memorable ‘big tune’. But it’s an attractive score, with lots of glitter and sweep in the music, and the orchestra played it impressively. Strangely, there was never a major professional production of the work at the Paris Opera until the early 1990’s. Lorenzo Passerini paced it well, and always gave room for the singers to breathe and (in some cases) extend their top notes…. The orchestra always sounded balanced, there was no raucous brass and with lots of aural space for some of the details of orchestration to appear. The performance of course featured two big stars, both of whom delivered in spades. Alagna must have something like 40 years of a career behind him, but his is still a big, powerful voice, sounding like someone 20 years younger, and with beautiful idiomatic phrasing. He is of a stature where he can do something I have never seen an opera singer do before – in the middle of Act 3 he suddenly stopped and said something to the effect of ‘I’m sorry; I’ve suddenly forgotten what comes next. Excuse me….’. There was a conflab with the prompter and the conductor restarted – no one seemed to mind and the spell was in no way broken! Ailyn Perez was deeply impressive – the first time I have heard her live. She’s at the height of her career, absolutely looked the part, sang her big act 4 aria with wonderfully soft tones, and she acts well. She was able to bring a sense of girlish excitement to the part in Acts 1 and 2. All the other parts were well sung. I am not clear about the provenance of the production – whether this is part of the ONP set-up or whether it is an independent organisation led by the theatre. Whatever it is, it clearly has the ability to put on some excellent shows, and the fact that Paris has this theatre, Opera Bastille, and Palais Garnier, on a par with Berlin for opera, and makes London’s provision shameful. It was clearly – before the Philharmonie – a major place for musicians to appear in Paris – the level I was on in the theatre has some wonderful old posters for the Berlin Philharmonic and Furtwangler in the early 30’s, Heiftez, Ansermet etc.

Published by John

I'm a grandfather, parent, churchwarden, traveller, chair of governors and trustee!. I worked for an international cultural and development organisation for 39 years, and lived for extended periods of time in Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Egypt and Ghana. I know a lot about (classical) music, but not as a practitioner, (particularly noisy late Romantics - Wagner, Mahler, Bruckner, Richard Strauss). I am well travelled and interested in different cultures and traditions. Apart from going to concerts and operas, I love reading, walking in the hills, theatre and wine-making. I'm also a practising Christian, though not of the fierce kind. And I'm into green issues and sustainability.

Leave a Reply